Rapture and the Second Coming
1. Difference Between the Rapture and the Second Coming of Jesus Christ
Rapture: The Rapture refers to a belief in the sudden, secret removal of the church (Christians) from the earth before a period of tribulation. This event, according to certain Christian interpretations, happens in two stages: the first is Christ coming "for" His saints, who will be caught up (raptured) to meet Him in the air.
Second Coming of Christ: The Second Coming, on the other hand, is a visible, public event where Christ will return "with" His saints to establish His millennial kingdom on earth. This event happens after the tribulation period and is meant for judgment and the renewal of the earth.
The key differences:
- Timing: The Rapture is said to occur before the tribulation, while the Second Coming happens afterward.
- Visibility: The Rapture is believed to be secret and invisible, while the Second Coming is a public and dramatic event.
- Purpose: The Rapture removes believers to heaven, while the Second Coming establishes Christ's reign on earth.
2. Different Views on the Rapture
There are several interpretations of the Rapture within Christian eschatology:
Pre-Tribulation Rapture: This view holds that the Rapture will occur before the seven-year tribulation period, sparing believers from the suffering that will follow. This is a common view among dispensationalists.
Mid-Tribulation Rapture: Some believe the Rapture will occur in the middle of the tribulation (after 3.5 years), before the more intense "Great Tribulation" begins.
Post-Tribulation Rapture: According to this view, the Rapture will occur at the end of the tribulation, coinciding with the Second Coming of Christ. The church endures the tribulation, but then meets Christ when He returns.
Partial Rapture Theory: Some believe that only faithful or spiritual Christians will be raptured before the tribulation, while others will be left behind to endure it.
Pre-Wrath Rapture: This view posits that the Rapture occurs before God's wrath is poured out on the earth but after much of the tribulation has taken place.
3. Biblical Passages Supporting the Rapture
Proponents of the Rapture concept often point to specific passages in the New Testament to justify their belief:
1 Thessalonians 4:16-17: "For the Lord himself will descend from heaven with a cry of command, with the voice of an archangel, and with the sound of the trumpet of God. And the dead in Christ will rise first. Then we who are alive, who are left, will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air..."
1 Corinthians 15:51-52: "Behold! I tell you a mystery. We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed, in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet."
John 14:1-3: Jesus promises to come back for His followers and take them to be with Him in the Father’s house.
Other verses sometimes cited include Matthew 24:36-41 (concerning two being taken and one left), Revelation 3:10, and Luke 17:34-37.
4. Development and Origins of the Rapture Concept
The concept of the Rapture is relatively modern. It began to take shape in the 19th century, largely due to the work of John Nelson Darby, a British theologian and a key figure in the development of dispensationalism. Darby’s teachings, particularly on the idea of a pre-tribulation Rapture, were spread through his writings and the Scofield Reference Bible, which popularized these interpretations among American evangelicals.
Before Darby, there is no clear historical evidence that the early church or medieval theologians held such a view of a separate, secret Rapture event distinct from the Second Coming of Christ.
5. Did Early Church Fathers Believe in the Rapture?
The early church fathers did not teach the concept of a pre-tribulation Rapture. Their focus was more on the visible return of Christ and the final resurrection of the dead, where the righteous would reign with Christ. Irenaeus, Tertullian, Augustine, and others spoke about Christ's return but without the idea of a separate, secret Rapture.
Instead, the early church fathers tended to view the tribulation as something the church would endure. The idea of being "caught up" (1 Thessalonians 4:17) was understood as part of the resurrection event at Christ's visible return, not as a secret event before the tribulation.
6. Refuting the Rapture Concept from a Biblical Perspective
To refute the Rapture doctrine, scholars and theologians point to several key arguments:
Context of 1 Thessalonians 4:16-17: This passage is often cited as evidence for the Rapture, but when read in context, it describes the return of Christ in connection with the resurrection of the dead, not a secret event. The imagery of meeting the Lord in the air reflects a common practice of meeting a dignitary outside a city to escort him back in triumph, which aligns with the idea of Christ's return to reign.
Unity of the Second Coming: Nowhere in the New Testament is there a clear distinction between a "secret" coming of Christ for His church and a visible, triumphant return. Instead, passages like Matthew 24:29-31 describe one event: Christ's return after the tribulation, gathering His elect.
Jesus' Teachings: In Matthew 24, Jesus explicitly states that His return will be visible and after the tribulation. He does not suggest a hidden event that would precede His public return.
Church Endurance: Throughout the New Testament, believers are called to endure tribulation. Jesus warns His disciples of coming persecution (John 16:33), and the Book of Revelation speaks to the perseverance of the saints during trials (Revelation 13:10). This undermines the idea that believers will be spared from tribulation.
Early Church Focus: As noted, the early church fathers did not separate the Rapture from the Second Coming. The notion of being taken up was seen as part of the resurrection and not a distinct event meant to avoid tribulation.
In summary, the Rapture doctrine, as developed in the 19th century, does not align with the traditional understanding of Christian eschatology, which sees Christ’s Second Coming as a singular, visible, and public event where He gathers His people and establishes His kingdom.
Read more...
